This is a very interesting comment. As I chronicle in The Real McCain, because of his Vietnam experience, McCain was reflexively against using military force during his early political career. He chastised others who disagreed, as is his way.
Yet, once he joined with the neo-conservatives and argued for overwhelming force even when war was unnecessary (see Iraq), he also used the Vietnam example.
In any case, his extensive military background, including his father and grandfather the admirals, does mean he is steeped in military culture. Good or bad? Maybe not black and white, but Harkin, a veteran himself, has some interesting things to say about this:
"He has a hard time thinking beyond that," Harkin told reporters. "I think he's trapped in that. Everything is looked at from his life experiences, from always having been in the military, and I think that can be pretty dangerous."
"It's one thing to have been drafted and served, but another thing when you come from generations of military people and that's just how you're steeped, how you've learned, how you've grown up."
Harkin, like McCain, was a Navy flier, though unlike McCain Harkin never saw combat.
Harkin said "there's nothing wrong with a career in the military…but now McCain is running for a higher office. He's running for commander in chief, and our Constitution says that should be a civilian. And in some ways, I think it would be nice if that commander in chief had some military background, but I don't know if they need a whole lot."
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About Campaign Silo
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
Harkin’s comments don’t make me any less supportive of McBush than I was before.
Boxturtle (*snark*)
Nor I
McCain’s comments that he is running for Commander in Chief has always troubled me. There’s more to the job of President of the United States than heading up the military and I think most of America is actually looking for less CinC type thinking.
A great book on the upbringing, influence and atmosphere commented on above is “Military Brats: Legacies of Childhood inside the Fortress” by Mary Wertsch.
please take this with a grain of salt - (the guy is Editor of Reason magazine) - he has also written a book about Maverilicious - in an excerpt from an interview with Democracy Now! he underscores Senator Harkin’s concerns -
Democracy Now!
crikey ! forgot to include the interviewee’s name: Matt Welch
McCain’s not running for Commander-in-Chief, he’s running for President. One of the several duties of the President is Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces, but he isn’t Commander-in-Chief of the rest of us.
Yet.
This is a Bushism we should work really hard to stamp out, as it’s part of the fascisming and militarizing of our entire American culture.
Amen, TSF. They’ve tried to imprint a horrid new definition of what our FedGov is, for now & forever. Time to junk it & go back to the Founding Fathers sterling original.
Thanks for this dosido. Will check it out!
Matt is actually a friend. And while we certainly don’t agree on everything, he is right on in his criticism of McCain as an authoritarian. I definitely recommend you check out what he has to say…
Very true Teddy. Very true.
you’re most welcome! my mother is a military brat and it explains a lot about her. My father did not serve but is authoritarian and they are a great match!
here are some excerpts I found online to give you a thumbnail sketch, but the book itself is worth a look. It’s old enough you can find it at a library, I think. The excerpt on “resilience” was particularly interesting as well as the one on trouble with authority figures.
excerpts
I don’t blame McCain for being the way he is, I just don’t think he’s cut out to be President. I completely agree with TeddySF and share his concern about the increased reverence of military solutions to everything.